Eurocert
Testing and Laboratory

RoHS and WEEE: Two Electronics Directives That Do Opposite Jobs

Split illustration contrasting RoHS substance restriction inside an electronic circuit board with WEEE recycling of the device at end of life

One line on a buyer's checklist, two completely different obligations

A Turkish electronics maker wins a contract with a German distributor and receives the compliance pack. Near the top sits one line: "RoHS and WEEE required." It looks like a single box to tick. Months later the products clear customs, sell well, and then a letter arrives from a national environmental register asking why the company has never reported a single kilogram of equipment placed on the market, with back-dated obligations attached. The RoHS side had been handled cleanly. The WEEE side was never recognised as separate. This is the most common and most expensive misunderstanding in electronics compliance: treating two directives that share nothing but an acronym habit as one task.

RoHS and WEEE travel together in tender documents because they govern the same products. They do almost opposite things. Reading them as one requirement is how exporters end up compliant on paper and exposed in practice.

Two directives, two different questions

RoHS, the Restriction of Hazardous Substances directive (2011/65/EU, extended by (EU) 2015/863), governs what may go into a product. It caps ten substances in electrical and electronic equipment: lead, mercury, cadmium, hexavalent chromium, two brominated flame retardants (PBB and PBDE) and four phthalates (DEHP, BBP, DBP, DIBP). The limits apply by weight in each homogeneous material, 0.1 % for most and 0.01 % for cadmium, not as an average across the whole device. That distinction matters, because a product is not one material. It is hundreds of homogeneous materials, each of which has to stay under the line.

WEEE, the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment directive (2012/19/EU), governs what happens to that product after someone is finished with it. It sets up extended producer responsibility: whoever places equipment on a national market has to help pay for its collection, treatment and recycling at end of life, register with the authority, and report how much was put on the market. One rule is about the chemistry going in. The other is about the waste coming out. Satisfying one tells an auditor nothing about the other.

Same products, opposite ends of the life cycle

The overlap that fuels the confusion is scope. Both directives use the same eleven categories of equipment, from large household appliances to medical devices and monitoring instruments, and both moved to open scope, meaning category 11 sweeps in any electrical or electronic equipment not already listed. RoHS reached open scope on 22 July 2019, WEEE on 15 August 2018. If a product needs electric current or electromagnetic fields to do its job, assume both directives apply until you have evidence that one does not. Two related rules sit just outside this pair and get bundled in by mistake: batteries fall under the separate EU Batteries Regulation, and packaging under its own packaging rules, so a careful product file keeps those streams distinct from RoHS and WEEE.

From there they diverge completely. RoHS lives at the design bench and in the bill of materials. WEEE lives in the waste stream and the national register. The table below sets the two side by side on the dimensions that decide what you actually have to do.

RoHS and WEEE: Two Electronics Directives That Do Opposite Jobs figure

Proving RoHS: a declaration, not a certificate

RoHS works as a self-declaration. No notified body issues a RoHS certificate: the manufacturer draws up its own EU Declaration of Conformity and applies the CE marking, whereas WEEE turns conformity into registering as a producer on each national register. Our RoHS compliance work is built around that homogeneous-material assessment rather than a single pass-or-fail test.

Two things still catch exporters out. First, RoHS exemptions are time-limited and expire, so a file that was correct two years ago can quietly fall out of date. Second, RoHS is not the only substance rule on the bench: REACH restricts substances of very high concern in parallel, which is why substance screening and SVHC testing usually belong in the same conversation as RoHS rather than a separate one. The CE marking that ties this together is the visible end of a longer evidence chain.

Discharging WEEE: registration, financing and reporting

WEEE runs the other way. It asks for almost nothing at the design bench and a great deal in each national market: there is no single European registration, so you register as a producer in every member state where you place equipment and report the quantities you put on that market on a recurring basis. The obligated producer is often the importer or brand owner rather than the upstream factory, and the procedural detail of registering, financing and reporting sits on our WEEE registration and reporting support page, where that per-country administration is the real work.

Where Turkish exporters lose time and money

Four mistakes recur. The first is reading "RoHS and WEEE" as one deliverable and resourcing it as one, when one is an engineering and documentation task and the other is a registration and reporting commitment that never ends. The second is assuming a registration in one country, or an EU declaration, covers the continent: WEEE financing is national, and twenty-seven markets can mean twenty-seven registrations. The third is letting a RoHS exemption lapse and shipping non-compliant product without noticing that the legal basis changed underneath. The fourth is forgetting the marking detail, because the wheeled-bin symbol, the producer identifier, and on many products a date mark, are part of conformity, not decoration.

For companies selling at home as well as abroad, Turkey transposes both regimes through its electrical and electronic equipment rules, so the domestic collection-and-recycling side and the substance restrictions run alongside the EU obligations rather than replacing them. Mapping the local EEE directive duties against each export market early keeps one set of work from contradicting another.

Getting both right, on purpose

The cleanest way to handle RoHS and WEEE is to stop thinking of them as a pair and start running them as two workstreams that happen to share a product list. One belongs to the people who choose materials and sign the declaration of conformity. The other belongs to whoever carries commercial responsibility in each market and has to register, finance and report there. Build that split into the project from the first sample, and the buyer's one-line checklist stops being a trap. If you want a second read on which obligations attach to a specific product and where, our teams handle the substance side and the producer-responsibility side together.